U.S. regions with the same population as California

Share this on Facebook download .zip with all pictures

>”…others see the status quo as just fine and resent the Supreme Court for legislating from behind the bench”

The Supreme Court doesn’t have legislative initiative. The only way they can engage in judicial review is if a case is so significant and flawed that it slowly climbs its way up through court after court after court. Even then, only a few are considered each year. Hundreds more sit on a pile- sometimes specifically because the Supreme Court wants to avoid the image of legislating from behind the bench and wants to give the legislature one more go at saving them the trouble. And that pile is getting bigger.

edit: Also the only way a case will climb that high is if a) a firm works for you pro bono (unlikely) or b) a very wealthy interest group is backing you. The fact that so many cases are sitting up at the top shelf tells me that the system is flawed.

>The American system of government considers both of these points of view to be equally legitimate, and equally deserving of representation.

Not since the early 20th century. There has been a fundamental shift towards central democracy and away from state power. Before the 17th Amendment was passed, state governments appointed/elected their own senators- the people of those states had no direct say in the matter.

Also look to the incorporation of many provisions of the bill of rights since the early 20th century. Prior to incorporation, many protections we now take for granted (i.e. guarantee of freedom of speech, religion and press) weren’t incorporated against the states. If a state wanted to deny you those liberties, they could.

Furthermore the whole incorporation business began because the southern states were so reluctant during Reconstruction. The modern states rights movements have their origins in this era, when southerners would go to every length to mitigate progress. This is why we had a brief period of black intellectuals and professionals after the civil war, only to be followed by decades of Jim Crow oppression. Yes, some good things did come out of it- like Posse Comitatus, but overall it left a legacy of agony.

edit: Also sometimes the congress has surrendered their responsibilities of compromise and consensus altogether. For instance, while they are constitutionally the sole body able to declare war, every major American war since WWII has been an executive action that was rubber-stamped into a real war by congress. And very very rarely has congress ever threatened to stop an executive war by cutting the defense budget.

>When society as a whole is ready for change, they will tell their legislator or vote in new ones who agree with them, and the legislature will pass laws respecting that change.

That’s a very trusting view of the system. Legislators spend most of their time fundraising and listening to insider lobbyists for a reason. I argue that more realistically, the great majority of legislators are most concerned with satisfying their financiers, while trying to hold on to a veneer of credibility to their constituents.

And this is also assuming that legislators cater to society as a whole. Let’s face facts: young people don’t vote, the poor don’t vote, racial minorities don’t vote and immigrants don’t vote. Well, I should say: Those groups don’t vote nearly as much as the entrenched, rich and the elderly. Say some young people want to reform social security by raising the retirement age so that the program doesn’t collapse by the time they’re elderly. Now a handful of young people might be able to fund a very very small political action committee, with no insiders, but they could never compete with the AARP.

>Just because they have fewer people doesn’t mean those people aren’t deserving of representation.

It also doesn’t mean that they deserve disproportionately large representation in the Senate.

Latest Comments
  1. Oughumde December 27, 2016
  2. Stramald December 27, 2016
  3. MeghannBoardman December 26, 2016
  4. CatharineDorrance December 23, 2016
  5. Oasi December 5, 2016
  6. AlexTibbs December 4, 2016
  7. Skelashat November 30, 2016
  8. RomaMcray November 28, 2016
  9. Oughumde November 26, 2016
  10. dreyer333 November 23, 2016
  11. christianson44 November 22, 2016
  12. rowles09 November 19, 2016
  13. Nyest November 15, 2016
  14. Oasi November 12, 2016
  15. CarlGuerrier November 8, 2016
  16. DomingaRico November 7, 2016
  17. lamoureux89 November 7, 2016
  18. milonekilone4 November 5, 2016
  19. lamoureux89 November 5, 2016
  20. barbozaIsland November 4, 2016
  21. VinitaRezendes November 4, 2016
  22. Oughumde November 3, 2016
  23. Emkim November 2, 2016
  24. Zapes November 2, 2016
  25. TyroneVautour November 1, 2016
  26. Endrr October 26, 2016
  27. poissonman88 October 22, 2016
  28. tauskny October 22, 2016
  29. Oasi October 19, 2016
  30. Nicolhowle October 16, 2016
  31. Isquaugh October 14, 2016
  32. Dotuton October 12, 2016
  33. Endvesa October 11, 2016
  34. ShellieFiles October 9, 2016
  35. Chaiwor October 4, 2016
  36. Nyest September 28, 2016
  37. Aselme September 25, 2016
  38. lawvercool3 September 17, 2016
  39. deardorff3 September 7, 2016
  40. Burageorm September 5, 2016
  41. Rac September 1, 2016
  42. urnisaw September 1, 2016
  43. Mcaaast9 August 29, 2016
  44. Sadys August 27, 2016
  45. Odynu August 26, 2016
  46. poissonman88 August 15, 2016
  47. LeotaBerkeley August 12, 2016
  48. tauskny August 9, 2016
  49. Iaor August 8, 2016
  50. Whail August 7, 2016
  51. Tabelque August 6, 2016
  52. StacyHickox August 2, 2016
  53. fogleodelia August 1, 2016
  54. Stramald July 31, 2016
  55. Hinoldo July 31, 2016
  56. Iaor July 29, 2016
  57. codayrzeszow July 17, 2016
  58. Hinoldo July 17, 2016
  59. Iworo July 13, 2016
  60. Eldrdan July 12, 2016
  61. Xojyw July 12, 2016
  62. persaud June 24, 2016
  63. Ongha June 22, 2016
  64. Imem June 13, 2016
  65. Xojyw June 11, 2016
  66. DavisGroce June 10, 2016
  67. RobbynDosch May 31, 2016
  68. Eldrdan May 24, 2016
  69. Yuania May 19, 2016
  70. Iss May 17, 2016
  71. Rodel May 17, 2016
  72. StacyHickox May 15, 2016
  73. Emtny May 2, 2016
  74. Adald April 27, 2016
  75. mcnabb April 27, 2016
  76. brusswszech April 23, 2016
  77. DonnieHeinlein April 21, 2016
  78. Esstiaing April 16, 2016
  79. guin7865 April 15, 2016
  80. Tonser April 13, 2016
  81. Kimskel April 12, 2016
  82. MeghannBoardman April 6, 2016
  83. Zapes April 6, 2016
  84. ShellieFiles April 3, 2016
  85. TyroneVautour April 3, 2016
  86. Korah March 26, 2016
  87. uruch March 23, 2016
  88. LeotaBerkeley March 20, 2016
  89. Darpolo March 14, 2016
  90. StacyHickox March 12, 2016
  91. goodellkol March 11, 2016
  92. Xojyw March 8, 2016
  93. Isquaugh March 6, 2016
  94. wasdenmzd March 4, 2016
  95. Kinild March 1, 2016
  96. bellowsE March 1, 2016
  97. Belacha March 1, 2016
  98. hyunsc2 March 1, 2016
  99. uruch March 1, 2016
  100. RomaMcray February 29, 2016
  101. lamoureux89 February 29, 2016
  102. Imem February 26, 2016
  103. Csmoak09 February 24, 2016
  104. DonnieHeinlein February 22, 2016
  105. Skelashat February 20, 2016
  106. Zapes February 16, 2016
  107. RomaMcray February 15, 2016
  108. Mcaaast9 February 12, 2016
  109. hyunsc2 February 11, 2016
  110. Wartin February 9, 2016
  111. Nyem February 7, 2016
  112. Jacquiline1999 February 1, 2016
  113. Yuania January 29, 2016
  114. DomingaRico January 28, 2016
  115. deardorff3 January 23, 2016
  116. LeolaBou January 18, 2016
  117. MilagroConti January 17, 2016
  118. Laeld January 16, 2016
  119. Usklor January 15, 2016
  120. ArletteMaddix January 14, 2016
  121. Nitanen January 14, 2016
  122. Kinild January 10, 2016
  123. Stramald January 8, 2016
  124. Oasi January 6, 2016
  125. Whail January 3, 2016
  126. Nulad December 29, 2015
  127. DomingaRico December 24, 2015
  128. Imem December 22, 2015
  129. ShahidAqq December 20, 2015
  130. Chawler December 18, 2015
  131. ornbakerset2 December 15, 2015
  132. Belacha December 13, 2015
  133. Esstiaing December 13, 2015
  134. Emtny December 11, 2015
  135. TyroneVautour December 8, 2015
  136. CristineLacomb December 6, 2015
  137. Tryt December 1, 2015
  138. Ingn November 24, 2015
  139. southwickship5 November 21, 2015
  140. Phois November 19, 2015
  141. DavisGroce November 17, 2015
  142. lawvercool3 November 17, 2015
  143. Chawler November 14, 2015
  144. Queton November 12, 2015
  145. Sordmiecz4 November 9, 2015
  146. vanderpool39 November 3, 2015
  147. deardorff3 November 1, 2015
  148. RSpofford October 30, 2015
  149. WendellAhmad October 27, 2015
  150. czakNorris1 October 20, 2015
  151. LacyMaberry October 19, 2015
  152. ucid October 7, 2015
  153. Zapes October 4, 2015
  154. Korah October 3, 2015
Comments are closed.
Click on Like Page, to get new amazing photo every day on facebook.
Thanks! I already Like.