Ukraine native languages according to 2001 census

Add to Facebook download .zip with all pictures

>A state just eliminates its minorities entirely, leaving a monocultural nation-state. This could be by actually killing them (the Turkish solution to the Armenian minority, the German solution to the “Jewish question”), or by expelling them or making conditions such that they will leave.

Well, remember that historically speaking, expelling minorities is fairly common and was what the Germans first attempted, well before they turned to genocide. So it seems like not that bad an option.

>A state forcibly integrates its minorities into the majority culture. This was what the Russian Empire and later the USSR at various periods tried to do with “Russification”, what Turkey has tried with “Turkification”, what Franco unsuccessfully tried to do with the Basques, etc.

>The state non-forcibly encourages minorities to join the majority culture, either by economic incentives or otherwise. I see this as what the U.S. generally does, though it isn’t official policy. However this is much harder to do if there are strongly established communities that don’t like the majority culture. Even harder to do if those communities are strong majorities in some areas.

America ought to be seen as a shining success in this regard. There is no modern day ethnic tension between different strands of European immigrants, for example. Even racial tension between blacks and whites is rare enough to be non-existant, at least compared to, say, Kurds and Turks. It’s ridiculously successful.

>Generally I find #3 and #4 more palatable than #1 and #2.

I disagree with this only halfway. It’s really bizarre and inexplicable to me, how you would rather see bloody wars for independence instead of relatively peaceful, but mandatory, cultural assimilation as in option 2. I do agree that 3 is better than 1 and usually better than 2, but I think 3 and 2 are far less distinct than you might believe and it is not as black and white an issue as it may seem. Forced assimilation is a very relative thing. Is it force, to make law that all public schools must be in the national language? This is a very contestable point already. Is it forced assimilation to require fluency or at least competence in the national language to gain citizenship? In some cases, I definitely think using state power to intentionally shape the national culture is preferable to letting the melting pot do its own thing naturally. I do have to admit though that the American example is a strong argument in favor of methods closer to 3 than to 2.

The latter part of 1 should be basically a last resort. The former is basically a concession of outright total failure. There should never be a reason for a militarily secure country facing no immediate external threats to be so threatened by an immigrant group that it has to kill them; so basically I think genocide, *committed by the state*, is a very rare thing that tends to happen in very desperate wartime conditions.

I guess the only argument I would really make is that any of these four options are preferable to a permanent multiculturalism. By permanent, I mean that I could support a state that makes temporary multicultural policies to support ease of transitioning for immigrant groups. I would not support any policies that support what amounts basically to balkanization within a country, as a permanent trend.

Latest Comments
  1. WendellAhmad December 27, 2016
  2. hyunsc2 December 27, 2016
  3. Undihin December 23, 2016
  4. MeghannBoardman December 15, 2016
  5. Belacha December 8, 2016
  6. urnisaw December 7, 2016
  7. DavisGroce December 5, 2016
  8. BuenaShore December 2, 2016
  9. Yonys November 28, 2016
  10. Imale November 19, 2016
  11. Iaor November 18, 2016
  12. wasdenmzd November 17, 2016
  13. Ashend November 11, 2016
  14. Queighty November 8, 2016
  15. Yuania November 6, 2016
  16. Neab November 1, 2016
  17. guin7865 October 31, 2016
  18. Lordnys October 25, 2016
  19. TakakoMelnick October 17, 2016
  20. StacyHickox October 16, 2016
  21. Tanenth October 15, 2016
  22. Rannund October 9, 2016
  23. Isquaugh October 6, 2016
  24. Isquaugh September 28, 2016
  25. Tabelque September 25, 2016
  26. VinitaRezendes September 20, 2016
  27. Oldtiavor September 19, 2016
  28. Emn September 17, 2016
  29. Skelashat September 15, 2016
  30. StacyHickox September 5, 2016
  31. Radbel September 5, 2016
  32. MilagroConti September 3, 2016
  33. Lavonne1 August 29, 2016
  34. YaekoPendelton August 26, 2016
  35. Ybele August 26, 2016
  36. BuenaShore August 24, 2016
  37. brusswszech August 18, 2016
  38. Reavis2000 August 12, 2016
  39. Belacha August 4, 2016
  40. Uskunte August 4, 2016
  41. Cerlory August 4, 2016
  42. Iceru July 30, 2016
  43. RebeckaGuyton July 29, 2016
  44. barbozaIsland July 29, 2016
  45. Unthon July 27, 2016
  46. DavisGroce July 26, 2016
  47. Eldoq July 24, 2016
  48. Nah July 21, 2016
  49. EviaBruss July 20, 2016
  50. GaleBostick July 17, 2016
  51. LatashiaReece July 13, 2016
  52. Emn July 11, 2016
  53. Hinoldo July 8, 2016
  54. guin7865 July 7, 2016
  55. Korah July 6, 2016
  56. Oldtiavor June 29, 2016
  57. Cerlory June 26, 2016
  58. Titus16 June 24, 2016
  59. Adir June 22, 2016
  60. ArletteMaddix June 18, 2016
  61. urnisaw June 13, 2016
  62. Daros June 10, 2016
  63. ucid June 9, 2016
  64. Rodel June 9, 2016
  65. Schiat June 8, 2016
  66. Awust June 7, 2016
  67. AdalbertoHumes June 5, 2016
  68. Korah June 5, 2016
  69. Skelashat June 2, 2016
  70. Kinild June 1, 2016
  71. Nyill May 31, 2016
  72. Umedar May 31, 2016
  73. AlexTibbs May 30, 2016
  74. hyunsc2 May 29, 2016
  75. Adald May 27, 2016
  76. Inest May 26, 2016
  77. Fitinack May 25, 2016
  78. Kimny May 23, 2016
  79. Tiarad May 21, 2016
  80. Neab May 20, 2016
  81. Emtny May 18, 2016
  82. Nulad May 16, 2016
  83. Korah May 8, 2016
  84. dorothywarkocz5 May 5, 2016
  85. Radbel May 2, 2016
  86. lamoureux89 May 2, 2016
  87. Rynepi April 29, 2016
  88. Chawler April 17, 2016
  89. osade April 12, 2016
  90. Korah April 7, 2016
  91. Imale April 5, 2016
  92. Sulghaeng April 5, 2016
  93. Claribel1 April 4, 2016
  94. Yonys April 1, 2016
  95. RSpofford March 31, 2016
  96. chrisman9020 March 31, 2016
  97. CarlGuerrier March 31, 2016
  98. Oslt March 29, 2016
  99. Imem March 24, 2016
  100. lawvercool3 March 23, 2016
  101. Garan March 19, 2016
  102. Nyest March 17, 2016
  103. Rodel March 14, 2016
  104. CarlGuerrier March 14, 2016
  105. lawvercool3 March 12, 2016
  106. LeotaBerkeley March 11, 2016
  107. Esstiaing March 9, 2016
  108. Umedar March 6, 2016
  109. Ingn March 5, 2016
  110. ThuBocanegra February 25, 2016
  111. Chawler February 22, 2016
  112. Garan February 21, 2016
  113. tauskny February 15, 2016
  114. Queighty February 12, 2016
  115. hyunsc2 February 12, 2016
  116. Emkim February 11, 2016
  117. Nicolhowle February 8, 2016
  118. kolinmcrae February 8, 2016
  119. hyunsc2 February 6, 2016
  120. Ashend February 5, 2016
  121. Chawler January 31, 2016
  122. Queighty January 30, 2016
  123. Hinoldo January 27, 2016
  124. urnisaw January 20, 2016
  125. Usklor January 20, 2016
  126. Oslt January 17, 2016
  127. Oslt January 14, 2016
  128. Tiaeld January 11, 2016
  129. rowles09 January 7, 2016
  130. Chawler January 2, 2016
  131. Ongha December 30, 2015
  132. BuenaShore December 27, 2015
  133. Garan December 25, 2015
  134. Oughumde December 23, 2015
  135. MeghannBoardman December 18, 2015
  136. vanderpool39 December 17, 2015
  137. Inest December 17, 2015
  138. Emtny December 14, 2015
  139. Adald December 14, 2015
  140. milonekilone4 December 10, 2015
  141. wasdenmzd December 7, 2015
  142. Cerlory December 6, 2015
  143. Odynu December 1, 2015
  144. Aselme November 24, 2015
  145. Dotuton November 23, 2015
  146. RobbynDosch November 19, 2015
  147. Imem November 18, 2015
  148. ThuBocanegra November 15, 2015
  149. ShahidAqq November 14, 2015
  150. Reavis2000 November 11, 2015
  151. Suloon November 11, 2015
  152. Daros November 10, 2015
  153. deardorff3 November 8, 2015
  154. Kimskel November 3, 2015
  155. CarlGuerrier November 2, 2015
  156. Esstiaing November 2, 2015
  157. Emtny November 2, 2015
  158. LeonardEdlund October 31, 2015
  159. Zapes October 25, 2015
  160. Chawler October 21, 2015
  161. MilesVickers October 17, 2015
  162. Tonser October 10, 2015
  163. Chawler October 8, 2015
  164. Csmoak09 October 7, 2015
  165. Ensulard October 5, 2015
  166. Cerlory October 4, 2015
  167. Stramald October 3, 2015
  168. garza77 October 3, 2015
  169. Suloon October 2, 2015
Comments are closed.
Click on Like Page, to get new amazing photo every day on facebook.
Thanks! I already Like.